Roofing Replacement vs. Repair: 7 Deciding Factors to Consider

All roofs deteriorate and eventually need to be replaced. But, when is the right time to re-roof? When are repairs enough? If you replace your roof too soon, you’ll waste money. If you wait too long, you risk ending up with roof leaks and expensive water damage.

When to re-roof depends on several factors, including the shingles’ wear and age, the climate in your area, and your home’s susceptibility to future damage.  If you’re conflicted and can’t decide whether to replace or repair, read on – we’ll help you make the right call.

Roofing Replacement vs. Repair: 7 Deciding Factors to Consider

Roofing Replacement vs. Repair: 7 Deciding Factors to Consider

Since roofing replacement is a rather costly investment, most homeowners want to postpone it for as long as they can, especially if the roof has reached the stage where it’s starting to have problems but is not completely shot. The cost of a shingle roof has roughly doubled during the last 10 years, after all so repairs might seem more desirable. Yet, many contractors will push for complete replacement, more focused on their bottom line than what’s best for their customer. So what’s the right call?

7 factors to consider in deciding whether to repair or replace

  • You roof’s age is one of the most important considerations. Most asphalt shingles have a lifespan of about 15 – 30 years. If the roof is damaged but most of it is still in good shape, a spot repair may make sense. But, if the roof is approaching (or past) 20 years old, replacing it may be the better way to go long-term.
  • If there’s a leak somewhere, an inspection will help you determine how widespread it is. Often, roofs will leak along flashing points. If this is the case, and the leak is isolated, a quick repair may be all that is necessary. If the roof is leaking in several places, a roofing replacement may be in order.
  • Give some thought to how long you intend to be in the home. If you’re planning to sell in the next few years, and the roof is in generally good condition, it may make more sense to have repairs done.
  • If you opt to replace your roof, you may be able to incorporate environmentally-friendly features that qualify for local or federal tax credits to offset the cost. Also, new materials are generally more energy efficient, last longer, and perform better so an upgrade is desirable long-term.
  • If you’re replacing your roof, you may find that the type and/or quality of roofing material you use can qualify you for significant discounts on your homeowner’s insurance policy. Materials that are more resistant to fire or wind and hail damage will often result in lower rates.
  • As you consider the costs, you may or may not be able to lay another layer of shingles over the existing roof, rather than removing the current layer and starting “from scratch”. At the same time, removing the old shingles will allow you to inspect the roof deck or sheathing, and add ice-and-water-shield membrane along the eaves (which can only be applied to a clean deck and will help prevent damage due to ice dams).
  • If you’re thinking about replacing your roof, don’t forget to consider “hidden costs”, including gutter replacement or landscape damage. A reputable roofing contractor will produce a comprehensive estimate detailing all of the project’s costs.

Repairs are less expensive but tend to be more of a short-term solution, while a new roof is a big expense but should last you for decades. Either way, make the right decision today and you won’t have to worry about leaks and damage when storms roll through.

Your Local Contractor Can Help

At All Roofing Solutions, we work regularly with homeowners considering the “replace vs. repair” question. As experienced residential roofing contractors, our dedicated team of professionals is ready to help you with making the right decision for YOU. We will give you sound, impartial advice on what preventative measures can be taken to extend the life of your roof, and whether replacement of repair is the better decision.

Whether you need quick repairs or a complete replacement, we take each project seriously. With nearly 20 years of experience in roof repair and installation, we make sure every job is done right, with quality products and following industry-leading standards.

Call today at 302-725-ROOF (7663) in Delaware or 610-551-ROOF (7663) in Pennsylvania.
From new roof installations to comprehensive repairs, we’ve got your covered!


  1. Posted May 19, 2017 at 2:48 pm | Permalink

    These are all good factors you have put together regarding the need for things to be replaced or repaired. Replacing allows you to use products that are current and new. Technology is finding ways to save energy more than ever these days. So having a new installation all together saves money in the long run..

  2. Posted May 21, 2017 at 6:03 am | Permalink

    Great blog. I can’t think of an 8th. Thanks guys.

  • Call All Roofing Solutions for a Free Estimate
  • Featured Project

    Roof Replacement, Middletown, DE 19709
    Roof Replacement, Middletown, DE 19709

  • What Our Clients Say

    "Your crew was fast, reliable and thorough. We now have a beautiful slate roof and couldn't be happier. Thank you!"

    Paulina M., Wilmington, DE

    "The attention to detail and quality work is what sets you apart. We will definitely recommend you as a reliable roofer."

    Mitch B., Newark, DE

    "Hands down the most reliable and friendly roofing company in Wilmington area. Kudos for job well done!"

    Julie C., Chester, PA

  • All Roofing Solutions uses only top notch materials! All Roofing Solutions, LLC BBB Business Review